Accompagnement et gouvernance

Scientific Integrity

Scientific Integrity

Scientific integrity refers to the set of rules and values that must govern research activities to ensure that they are honest, impartial, objective, and scientifically rigorous.

The 2020 Research Programming Act (LPR) entrusted Hcéres (High Council for the Evaluation of Research and Higher Education) with new responsibilities regarding scientific integrity. The Ofis (French Office for Scientific Integrity) is responsible for carrying out these responsibilities.

As defined in the Research Code (Article L. 211-2), scientific integrity is essential to the proper functioning of research communities and forms the foundation of a relationship of trust between the research community and other sectors of society.

The European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity (2011, revised in 2017 and 2023) sets forth the common principles of good research practices

→ Reference documents on scientific integrity: www.ofis-france.fr

The Four Principles

  • Reliability in design, methodology, analysis, and the use of resources.

  • Respect for colleagues, research participants, society, ecosystems, cultural heritage, and the environment.

  • Honesty in the design, conduct, evaluation, and dissemination of research, in a transparent, fair, comprehensive, and objective manner.

  • Responsibility for research activities—from conception to publication—including their management and organization; for training, supervision, and mentoring; and for the broader implications of research.

Scientific Integrity / Professional Conduct / Research Ethics

Scientific integrity, research ethics, and professional conduct are three essential components of responsible research conduct.

Scientific integrity refers to best practices in the production and dissemination of scientific knowledge. It ensures that research activities are honest and rigorous.

Professional ethics refers to a set of obligations specific to the practice of a profession. In France, when a researcher is a public employee, his or her obligations are governed by the General Code of the Civil Service.

Research ethics concerns, on the one hand, the major questions raised by certain scientific developments and, on the other hand, more operational issues regarding the compliance of research protocols with applicable laws and ethical guidelines.

► Learn more: Scientific integrity, professional ethics, and research ethics: What are the differences?

What is a breach of scientific integrity?

Any practice that undermines the reliability of results and the proper functioning of research communities may constitute a breach of scientific integrity. A breach may involve any aspect of research activities across all disciplines.

Quelques exemples de manquement pouvant affecter

  • La planification et la mise en œuvre du projet de recherche : défaut d’obtention des autorisations nécessaires (approbation éthique, consentement des participants) ; non-respect des protocoles autorisés ; utilisation abusive de fonds de recherche.
  • La gestion et les pratiques en matière de données de toute nature (y compris corpus de textes, archives, images…) : falsification ou fabrication ; gestion ou archivage délibérément déficients ; rétention non justifiée juridiquement, omission ou sélection non justifiée scientifiquement ; traitements statistiques problématiques; embellissement non mentionné.
  • Les pratiques en matière de publication, de communication et d’autorat : plagiat ; signature abusive ou absence de reconnaissance d’une contribution ; autoplagiat ; non-conformité aux exigences d’usage de l’IA ; citations abusives ou biaisées ; défaut d’impartialité ou de transparence lors d’une prise de parole publique.
  • Les interactions entre pairs : peer-reviewing biaisé, appropriation de projets de recherche ou d’idées, déficit d’encadrement, empêchement indu de l’avancement des travaux d’un pair, accusation non fondée de manquement.

La non-déclaration de liens ou de conflits d’intérêt peut également constituer un manquement, ainsi que la violation des lois qui encadrent la recherche sur les personnes ou sur les animaux.

Dans leurs formes les plus graves – ce peut être notamment le cas pour la fabrication, la falsification de données et le plagiat – les manquements sont passibles de sanctions disciplinaires.

Scientific Integrity at Gustave Roussy

Professor Eric Solary (RIS@gustaveroussy.fr) is the Scientific Integrity Officer (RIS) at Gustave Roussy (https://www.ofis-france.fr/annuaire/)

The responsibilities of the RIS are defined by the decree of December 27, 2023, and enshrined in the Research Code. In accordance with this decree, the RIS at Gustave Roussy:

  • helps define the institution’s policy on scientific integrity,
  • coordinates awareness-raising and training initiatives, and organizes measures to prevent and detect violations of scientific integrity requirements
  • receives inquiries and reports of “breaches of scientific integrity ” (as defined in a previous chapter), which it investigates impartially and confidentially, including through hearings and investigations, where appropriate in coordination with the scientific integrity officers of other relevant institutions or foundations;
  • guarantees the confidentiality of the procedure for handling reports, ensures compliance with the principle of adversarial proceedings, and maintains the transparency of this procedure for both the individuals implicated and those who filed the report;
  • promptly submits a report to the Director General of Gustave Roussy to enable him or her to decide on the appropriate course of action for each report investigated;
  • ensures that data and publications affected by the breach of scientific integrity requirements are reported to the parties concerned;
  • reports to the Director General of Gustave Roussy any internal policies or practices that do not provide sufficient safeguards in terms of scientific integrity.

Le Professeur Eric Solary est le référent à l’intégrité scientifique (RIS) de Gustave Roussy.

Scientific Integrity at Gustave Roussy

Professor Eric Solary (RIS@gustaveroussy.fr) is the Scientific Integrity Officer (RIS) at Gustave Roussy (https://www.ofis-france.fr/annuaire/)

The responsibilities of the RIS are defined by the decree of December 27, 2023, and enshrined in the Research Code. In accordance with this decree, the RIS at Gustave Roussy:

  • helps define the institution’s policy on scientific integrity,
  • coordinates awareness-raising and training initiatives, and organizes measures to prevent and detect violations of scientific integrity requirements
  • receives inquiries and reports of “breaches of scientific integrity ” (as defined in a previous chapter), which it investigates impartially and confidentially, including through hearings and investigations, where appropriate in coordination with the scientific integrity officers of other relevant institutions or foundations;
  • guarantees the confidentiality of the procedure for handling reports, ensures compliance with the principle of adversarial proceedings, and maintains the transparency of this procedure for both the individuals implicated and those who filed the report;
  • promptly submits a report to the Director General of Gustave Roussy to enable him or her to decide on the appropriate course of action for each report investigated;
  • ensures that data and publications affected by the breach of scientific integrity requirements are reported to the parties concerned;
  • reports to the Director General of Gustave Roussy any internal policies or practices that do not provide sufficient safeguards in terms of scientific integrity.

Contact

Address

Gustave Roussy